Comparison of two scenarios showed that, in the second scenario less bias in estimation and fewer mistakes in variable selection was seen. Respondents in service occupations less likely to report income missing not at random nmar. The dependent variable for this example is attack, coded 0 if the subject did not have a heart attack and 1 if he or she did. Using numerous examples and practical tips, this book offers a nontechnical explanation of the standard methods for missing data such as listwise or casewise deletion as well as two newer and, better methods, maximum likelihood and multiple imputation. There are three types of missing values allison, 2001. To compare these two algorithms, i generated 10,000 observations on three variables x, y. Is there much data missing from a few subjects or a little data missing from each of several. There are many types of missing data and different reasons for data being missing. We will say that these values are mcar if the probability of missing data on y is unrelated to the value of y itself or to the values of any other variable in the data set. Handling data with three types of missing values jennifer a. At present, his principal research is on methods for analyzing longitudinal data, especially those for determining the causes and consequences of events, and on methods for handling missing data. Missing data software, advice, and research on handling. Some general guidelines for choosing missing data handling. Solutions for missing data in structural equation modeling rufus lynn carter marymount university.
Missing data form a problem in every scientific discipline, yet the techniques required to handle them are complicated and often lacking. Multiple imputation is rapidly becoming a popular method for handling missing data, especially with easytouse software like proc mi. Cheema university of illinois at urbanachampaign champaign, il the effect of a number of factors, such as the choice of analytical method, the handling method for missing data, sample size, and proportion of missing data, were examined to. A former guggenheim fellow, allison received the 2001 lazarsfeld award for distinguished contributions to sociological methodology. Missing data mechanisms there are different assumptions about missing data mechanisms. This is one of the books available for loan from academic technology services see statistics books for loan for other such books, and details about borrowing. Solutions for missing data in structural equation modeling. Marlin doctor of philosophy graduate department of computer science university of toronto 2008 learning, inference, and prediction in the presence of missing data are pervasive problems in machine learning and statistical data analysis. The first concern is the randomness or nonrandomness of the missing data.
In this paper, however, i argue that maximum likelihood is usually better than multiple imputation for several important reasons. Drawing on his 25 years of experience researching, teaching, and consulting in quantitative areas, the author presents both freq. Missing data analysis in practice provides practical methods for analyzing missing data along with the heuristic reasoning for understanding the theoretical underpinnings. By missing data, i mean data that are missing for some but not all variables and for some but not all cases. The effect of increasing the proportion of missing data for restraint use on results for a separate covariate lateral impact with a fixed proportion of missing data 4% in a multivariable logistic regression model mar pattern. Handling incomplete data incorrectly can lead to bias, overcon dent intervals, and inaccurate inferences. His current methodological research is on the analysis of longitudinal data, especially with determining the causes and consequences of events, and on methods for handling missing data. Two algorithms for producing multiple imputations for missing data are evaluated with simulated data. Summary the prevention and treatment of missing data in. Full information maximum likelihood for missing data in r. Whether youve loved the book or not, if you give your honest and detailed thoughts then people will find new books that are right for them. How do i use full information maximum likelihood fiml estimation to address missing data in r. Test to see if the missing data are biased or if they are randomly distributed along each of the other ivs and dvs of interest.
Missing data strategies from completecase analysis to modelbased methods each carry assumptions about the nature of the mechanism that causes the missing data. Allison university of pennsylvania address correspondence to paul d. Section 2 and 3 explain the different missing data mechanisms and the patterns of missingness. Missing data techniques for structural equation modeling. Conventional methods such as listwise or pairwise deletion generally do a poor job of using all the available. Missing at random or not missing at random a basic distinction is that data are a missing completely at random mcar, b missing at. Missing data is a common problem in realworld settings and particularly relevant in healthcare applications where researchers use electronic health records ehr and. Some general guidelines for choosing missing data handling methods in educational research jehanzeb r. Missing data mechanisms missing completely at random mcar missing value y neither depends on x nor y example. Yet textbooks and software commonly assume that data are complete, and the topic of how to handle missing data is not often discussed outside statistics journals. Good missing data analysis solutions are available, but practical information about implementation of these solutions has been lacking. Allison multiple imputation is rapidly becoming a popular method for handling missing data, especially with easytouse software like proc mi. If the missing values are not handled properly by the researcher, then heshe may end up drawing an inaccurate inference about the data.
The first edition of statistical analysis with missing data has been a standard reference on missingdata methods. Create dummy variables representing cases that are missing data. A cautionary tale, sociological methods and research, 28, 309. Other readers will always be interested in your opinion of the books youve read. Multiple imputation fills in missing values by generating plausible numbers derived from distributions of and relationships among observed variables in the data set. Missing data are a common occurrence and can have a significant effect on the conclusions that can be drawn from the data. Descriptives for each variable, the number of nonmissing values are used. Influence of pattern of missing data on performance of. Learn dealing with missing data from university of maryland, college park. Missing data have long plagued those conducting applied research in the social, behavioral, and health sciences. Allison university of pennsylvania as with other statistical methods, missing data often create major problems for the estimation of structural equation models sems. Missing data are a rule rather than an exception in quantitative research.
A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. Allison introduction missing data are ubiquitous in psychological research. If data are missing on a variable for all cases, then that variable is said to be latent or unobserved. Allisons early research focused on career patterns of academic scientists. This course will cover the steps used in weighting sample surveys, including methods for adjusting for nonresponse and using data external to the survey for calibration. An investigation of missing data methods for classi. I am doing asymptotically distribution free estimation in amos due to a data set that is not normal and has ordinal data. Missing data techniques for structural equation modeling paul d. For the other variables, the proportion of cases with missing data is generally small, with a maximum of 10 percent missing for frelg.
Chi square test for categorical variables ttest for continuous variables. Read the prevention and treatment of missing data in. Only one predictor variable clt6 has no missing data. Moreover, most of these studies limited their coverage to the simplest missing data scenario, namely, missing completely at random mcar, while our study shows that the missing data generating process is one of the two crucial criteria in determining the best missing data method.
Missing data problems in machine learning benjamin m. To know how any one command handles missing data, you should consult the spss manual. We should emphasize that our main aim in this paper was not to identify the variables that govern drug injection in prison, but to address impact of pattern of missing data on performance of imputation methods. Section 4 presents the main methods for dealing with missing data. Flexible imputation of missing data buuren, stef van. The concept of missing values is important to understand in order to successfully manage data. Software using a propensity score classifier with the approximate bayesian bootstrap produces badly biased estimates of regression coefficients when data on predictor variables are missing at random or missing completely at random. Enders 2003 stated that a missing rate of 15% to 20% was common in educational and psychological studies. Allison, statistical horizons, haverford, pa, usa abstract multiple imputation is rapidly becoming a popular method for handling missing data, especially with easytouse. University of connecticut, 20 abstract missing values present challenges in the analysis of data across many areas of research. Is there a package you would recommend, and what are typical steps. It is important to understand how spss commands used to analyze data treat missing data. We offer tools and practical advice on using two rigorous methodsmaximum likelihood and multiple imputationto analyze data with missing values. He goes on to state that while his method using lisrel pro.
The prevention and treatment of missing data in clinical trials concludes that a more principled approach to design and analysis in the presence of missing data is both needed and possible. In statistics, missing data, or missing values, occur when no data value is stored for the variable in an observation. A typology of missing data there are several types of missing data patterns, and each pattern can be caused by different factors. Statistical analysis of data sets with missing values is a pervasive problem for which standard methods are of limited value.
390 3 1149 1061 1498 1375 1172 503 1327 494 666 1319 1405 735 990 416 463 927 915 246 635 726 63 514 1123 1336 577 779 53 1130 1105 1451 307 579 929 1162 1202 1057